Best Dark Roast K-Cups for Keurig: Top Picks 2021

Best Dark Roast K-Cups for Keurig

Best Dark Roast K-Cups for Keurig: The Keurig Coffee Brewing system has drastically changed how people make and drink coffee in their everyday routines. Within minutes, a busy person can have their cup of coffee and be out the door and on their way with minimal cleanup and an excellent tasting cup of coffee in their hand.

When you go to the store, it’s tough not to see those little pods filled with coffee that are ready to be put into your Keurig machine, otherwise known as K-Cups. These K-Cups have invaded the majority of office spaces and kitchens. As a result of the popularity, many large brands have begun to make coffee pods with their specialty coffees, which are compatible with the Keurig Machines. Here’s our list of the Best Dark Roast K-Cups for Keurig on the market right now.

Top 10 Best Dark Roast K-Cups for Keurig 2021

Green Mountain Coffee...image Green Mountain Coffee Roasters Dark Magic, 72 Count Check Price on Amazon
Perfect Samplers Dark...image Dark Roast Coffee Pod Variety Pack, 40 Pack Check Price on Amazon
Starbucks Dark Roast...image Starbucks Dark Roast K-Cup Coffee Pods- 6 boxes (60 pods total) Check Price on Amazon
SF Bay Coffee...image SF Bay Coffee French Roast 80 Ct Dark Roast Coffee Pod Check Price on Amazon
Barista Prima Coffeehouse...image Barista Prima Coffeehouse Italian Roast Coffee, Italian Roast Coffee (Count of 96) Check Price on Amazon
Eight O'Clock Coffee...image Eight O'Clock Coffee Dark Italian Roast, Dark Roast Coffee, 72 Count Check Price on Amazon
The Original Donut...image The Original Donut Shop Dark, 72 Count Check Price on Amazon
Emeril's Big Easy...image Emeril's Big Easy Bold, K-Cup for Keurig Brewers, 24 Count (Pack of 2) Check Price on Amazon
Includes Barista Prima...image Includes Barista Prima Italian Roast Coffee K-Cups for Keurig Brewers, 24 Count (Pack of 2) - Total of 48 K-Cups (Packaging May Vary) Check Price on Amazon
Amazon Brand -...image Amazon Brand - 100 Ct. Solimo Dark Roast Coffee Pods, Compatible Check Price on Amazon

1. Green Mountain Dark Roast K-Cups:


Best Dark Roast K-Cups for Keurig

This product is a dark roast coffee that gives you an intense flavor with underlying dried fruit and chocolate. Notes It is a certified Orthodox Union Kosher product, with beans sourced from Sumatra, Costa Rico, Colombia, and Kenya. This means that the coffee brewed is less likely to be acidic, which can prevent acid reflux after drinking it. A potential issue with this product is that the cups tend to burst open during brewing. Keeping a close eye on them may be necessary.

  • Bold flavor
  • No aftertaste
  • Guilt-free brewing
  • Expensive

2. 40-Count COFFEE Brewer’s Variety Sampler:


Best Dark Roast K-Cups for Keurig 2020

This dark roast sampler allows you to try several different brands of dark coffee. This works great if you are looking to try something new or if you are purchasing it as a gift for someone. One drawback of a product like this that offers all bold choices is that they may not fit in with the boldness that you’re used to seeking out in your coffee. Some may see weakness in you if you’re used to trying darker blends.

  • Variety
  • Great way to explore
  • Expensive
  • Not a great value

3. Starbucks Italian Dark-Roast K Cups:


Dark Roast K-Cups for Keurig Top Picks

This French roast is from a brand with a reputation for excellent coffee. This type of coffee will give you a fuller flavor and a more intense body to your drink. It also has a smokiness to it that many people enjoy. When shipped, this product comes as a box of loose pods. Unless damaged, these pods are deemed safe to use. However, this feature may make some people uncomfortable. It is also important when a product is shipped like this that you monitor for expired cups.

  • Good coffee
  • Known brand
  • Expensive
  • Specialty roast

4. San Francisco Bay Compatible Brewers:


This French roast gourmet coffee product is sure to please as it contains some of the best coffees from Central and South America. The beans are shade-grown, which lowers the acid content of the coffee. The product gives you a low acid content in your brew, which can benefit many people that drink coffee. An additional benefit is that the cups that contain the coffee are more of a filter instead of plastic. This makes them better for the environment because we are sending less waste to landfills. They are also packaged in a bag that states it is compostable. It’s easy to appreciate a company who takes this additional step to create a healthier product for their customer base.

An additional positive impact to discuss related to this coffee brand is that a portion of every purchase of these k cups is funneled into a program called Grown for Good. This program helps benefit other communities and farmers in the area.

  • Low amount of acid
  • Contain filter
  • Healthy
  • Expensive

5. Barista Prima Coffeehouse Brewers:


Dark Roast K-Cups for Keurig

This product comes in seven flavors total and a selection of five different sizes, giving you the chance to choose exactly what you need. The Italian roast has an extra bold kick that is sure to please the coffee drinker looking for that darker brew. The coffee brewed from this k-cup gives a fruity and intense flavor with berry notes and a hint of a Smokey flavor.

  • Kosher free
  • Gluten-free
  • Smokey

6. Eight O’Clock Coffee Italian Single Serve:


Dark Roast K-Cups for Keurig

This dark roast Italian blend coffee will be sure to please the dark coffee lover. It has an intense and full-bodied flavor that also includes some subtle notes of chocolate. This product is certified Kosher, which can benefit a larger group of people. It also gives peace of mind about how and where the product is processed. Another perk is that this product provides you a recipe for s’mores iced coffee, using the dark roast grounds, which sounds incredible. The product also contains loose packaging, but it is a personal preference if you agree with this or not.

The issue with loose packaging, like what this company offers, is that it is more challenging to keep track of expiration dates. It would be frustrating to pay for a shipment of dark roast coffee and have to throw many cups away because they are expired and not safe for drinking.

  • Dark roast ground
  • Certified by kosher
  • Expensive
  • Loose packaging

7. Original Donut Shop Keurig Single-Serve:


This dark original donut roast is from a leading brand and boasts a delicious and bold flavor. There are also no additional ingredients added, and the product is certified Kosher. These pods can brew up to 12 ounces per pod, and they also contain more coffee than their previous versions.  Both of these features make them a great option if you are looking for a strong cup of coffee. The darker blends tend to have a slightly lower amount of caffeine, which is made up for by the more intensely bold flavor.

  • No extra ingredients
  • Certified by Kosher
  • A lower amount of caffeine
  • Excess bold flavor

8. Emeril Coffee Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup:


Emeril Coffee Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup

This will give you coffee with a dark and robust flavor that will taste great regardless of whether you drink it black or with milk or cream. The bonus of drinking a dark roast is that it allows you to still taste the flavor of the coffee no matter what you add to your cup. These cups come from a brand with a reputation for providing quality products. Another perk of these is that they are certified Orthodox Union Kosher, making them perfect for many groups of people. This product brews strong and bold no matter what size of cup you use.

  • Dark and robust flavor
  • Great dark
  • Certified by Orthodox Union Kosher
  • Bitter taste

9. Barista Prima Coffeehouse Italian Roast:



Barista Prima Best Dark Roast K-Cups for Keurig

This may be one of the best Keurig Coffee K-Cups you can buy if you like dark roast coffee. The Italian Roast K-Cups have a deep, rich, smokey flavor and an aroma that will get everyone gathering around while it’s brewing. If you’re into decaf coffee, then the Barista Prima Italian Roast K-Cups may be the best Keurig Coffee for you, as the flavor varies only slightly between decaf and regular caffeine coffee pods.

  • Smokey flavor
  • Nice aroma
  • Expensive

10. Solimo Dark Roast Keurig K-Cup Pods:



Solimo Dark Roast Keurig K-Cup Pods

Amazon’s foray into K-cups, Solimo’s Dark Roast Coffee Pods, got our number two rank because it delivers quality and value. Most things Amazon tries wind up being pretty successful, and Solimo’s coffee pods are no exception. Dark roasts are known for their bold, full flavor, and these pods hit that like a well-tuned note. They also do it at a per-unit price that is frankly pretty amazing. You can spend twice what you would on these and get lower quality. One drawback is that this coffee can have a bitter aftertaste. In general, because beans for dark coffees are roasted for so long, that can be an issue, but it seems a little more pronounced with Solimo. It’s also got a minimal distribution. If you’re an Amazon customer, you’re set. If you like to shop at different online retailers, you’re out of luck.

  • Very affordable
  • Great quality
  • Limited distribution
  • Aftertaste issues
  • Roast basics

Every coffee bean starts green. They smell vaguely like grass but have no real flavor. The flavor comes from the roasting process. The longer you roast the bean, the darker it becomes. There is some variation depending on the kind of bean, but for the most part, a darker bean is that way because it’s been roasted longer. There are a couple of things that happen, the longer you roast beans.

The first is that the flavor is less and less based on that original raw coffee bean flavor and more based on the roasting process itself. The second is that the longer you roast beans, the more caffeine are destroyed. For example, while espresso is a dark roast and usually associated with a quick, massive jolt of energy, in reality, it has less caffeine pound-for-pound than a light roast.


A final consideration is the price. Coffee made in a Keurig is excellent and flavorful, but if you’re a real coffee snob, there is a wide range of brewing techniques that will squeeze every last iota of flavor from your beans. The problem is that they’re labor- and time-intensive. On the other hand, K-cups might be really fast and efficient, but they’re also among the costliest ways to brew coffee at home. You can probably save a few bucks without seeing a noticeable drop-off in coffee quality if you prioritize value.

Read more about Keurig 2.0: Best Recommendation & Buyer’s Guide 2021

Best Dark Roast K-Cups for Keurig – The Final Verdict

Hopefully, this list of the best dark roast coffee K-Cups has given you a good list of Keurig K-Cup flavors to look out for the next time you go shopping. Now, you’ll discover your new favorite K-Cup blend. When looking at K-Cups, there are many options out there to choose from. At the end of the day, the best option for you will be a blend with the flavor, caffeine content, and amount of K-Cups you want.

Read more about Why is Keurig not pumping water? Best possible solutions

Also, remember that many brands package their K-Cups in different sizes and amounts, so there’s bound to be one that works best for you.

Recent Posts